🎶 Rethinking the Canon


Dear Friends,

Last weekend I gave a presentation to the Maryland Music Teachers Association State Conference, with my session: “'If You Like That, You’ll Love This!': Repertoire Alternatives for Overplayed Pieces."

The genesis of this talk was the fact that as pianists, we have so many options for repertoire available to us, but I have observed while judging competitions, giving masterclasses, and listening to auditions that piano students seem to play the same few pieces over and over. In the session, I share examples of lesser-known pieces that could “substitute” for some of the more famous, overplayed pieces, thinking in terms of the pedagogical reason for assigning the piece in the first place.

One of the works I demonstrate in this talk is Mélisande, a short piece by French composer Mélanie Bonis (professionally, she went by "Mel" to obscure her gender). Bonis was a a student of Cesar Franck and a contemporary of Claude Debussy. Mélisande is a piece from a larger work called Femmes de legende (Legendary Women): a series of pieces, each named after a famous fictional woman from legend: Mélisande, Desdémona, Ophélie, Viviane, Phoebé, Salomé, Omphale.

There is a good, yet incomplete IMSLP page of works by Mel Bonis - but if you’re interested in obtaining scores of her music, I recommend checking out Furore Press, who has published 11 volumes (so far) of her piano music.

Throughout my ongoing exploration of works by composers such as Mel Bonis, Cécile Chaminade, Amy Beach, Maria Hester Park, and others, I have been pondering the question: how much creative expression has been lost to posterity by the stubborn belief that women were less worthy than men to study and learn the art of composition? Even well into the 20th century, woman after woman in Western classical music who showed promise as a child had her education and/or professional growth stunted, explicitly and solely due to her gender.

Even those who succeeded did so despite being a woman and did not necessarily pave the way to more opportunities for other women or change the minds of the men in charge.

For example, Joachim Raaf, the director of the Hoch Conservatory of Music, where Clara Schumann served as the sole female faculty member, said: “With the exception of Madame Schumann there is no woman and there will not be any women employed in the Conservatory. As for Madame Schumann, I count her as a man.”

Of Cécile Chaminade, first woman to receive the French Légion d'Honneur, composer Ambroise Thomas said, "This is not a woman who composes, but a composer who is a woman."

(I could go on, but this is a newsletter, so I'll stop there in the interest of space!)

I’m glad the practice of re-discovering works by composers outside the “typical” canon is gaining in popularity. Now that more of this music is coming to light, there are truly some gems to discover.

I'm always looking for new and "off-the-beaten-path" pieces and composers to discover - what interesting repertoire are you familiar with that you wish more people knew about? Write back and let me know!

Happy Practicing! 🎹

-Kate


In every newsletter I share one practice tip based on that month’s practice theme. October’s theme is “Note-Learning.”

Today's Practice Tip: Learn From the End!

One of the greatest gifts you can give to your future piano-playing self is to learn a piece from the end. Just yesterday in a lesson, a student played through a movement of a Beethoven sonata from memory; in the first third of the performance, she had a few memory slips, but as she kept playing, her confidence and authority grew. When she finished, she laughed ruefully and said to me, "And that's why we learn from the end!"

The way to learn a piece (or movement) from the end is to divide it into manageable sections and learn them one by one, back to front.

The reason this is effective is because, like the student I just mentioned, as you play, your confidence increases (because you started at the end and you therefore know it best)!

Also: learning from the end ensures that you will get to the more technically difficult parts sooner, giving you more time to master them. Most of the time, the piece’s most difficult passages are NOT at the beginning.

Learning a piece from the end will make it easier to memorize the piece when it comes time to do so (if you don’t already memorize as you learn), because you will be solidifying the END of the piece before you’ve even learned the beginning.

Whenever I show this method of learning a new piece to my students, they are suddenly able to make much more rapid progress in the note-learning phase of their pieces. Students tell me that they feel much more empowered to learn their music quickly, and that they especially appreciate knowing a systematic approach to this part of the learning process, which can often feel haphazard and frustrating.

This week’s exercise: For a piece you are currently in the “note-learning” stage for, write numbers into your score to create sections from the back of the piece to the front. The length of each section is entirely up to you; it should be a manageable segment of the piece. As an example, if you are looking at a sonata movement, you might have 6-8 sections, and if you are working on an invention that is two pages long, each section might be 2-3 lines long. Put each section break in a place where the texture changes or there’s a natural break in the musical flow.

Then, start practicing from the end by carefully learning the first section (at the end of the piece), and then, only after you feel secure with that, move on to the next section. Each day, review the work you have done on the piece up to that point, and then add onto it with new sections.

Quote of the Week

"We shall never become musicians unless we understand the ideals of temperance, fortitude, liberality and magnificence.” - Plato

Tutorial: Two Against Three Rhythms

This week's video is a tutorial about two against three rhythms. A surprising number of piano students struggle with this - even those learning more advanced repertoire can sometimes have difficulty playing smooth polyrhythms in each hand.

Playing two against three rhythms requires not only understanding the rhythm in each hand and the mathematics of how the hands fit together, but also making the mental leap to feeling the larger beat and letting each hand independently divide the beat into even subdivisions.

My intention in making this video was to create a step-by-step tutorial to help students make that leap.

​Click here or on the image below to watch the video!

2 vs 3 Handout

I made a handout to go with the video about 2 against 3 rhythms. It has some of the exercises and simplifications I go over in the tutorial. You can get it here.

Work with me!

At Butler University I teach undergraduate and master's-level pianists. Our 2024 audition dates are January 19, Feb 2, 9, 16, and 19. Here's a link to the application process. Interested in learning more about studying at Butler? Contact me here!

Upcoming Dates and Events:

Nov 3, 10:30 am: Lilly Hall, Butler University. I'll be giving a presentation to the Indianapolis Piano Teachers Association: "'If You Like That, You'll Love This!' - Piano Repertoire Alternatives for Overplayed Pieces."

Nov 5, 2:00 pm: Eidson-Duckwall Recital Hall, Butler University (Indianapolis, IN). Piano Studio Recital, featuring Butler University piano students. Click here for the event and live stream link.​

Jan 30, 2024, 7:30: Eidson-Duckwall Recital Hall, Butler University (Indianapolis, IN). Trio Recital: works for horn, violin and piano, with Zachary Cooper and Mélanie Clapiès.

Feb 27, 204, 7:30 pm: Schrott Center for the Arts, Butler University. I will be performing Gershwin's Rhapsody in Blue with the Butler Wind Ensemble, to celebrate the 100th anniversary of this piece.

Did someone forward this email to you?

​Subscribe here and don't miss an issue!​​

Copyright 2023 Kate Boyd, All rights reserved.

​Unsubscribe from Notes from the Piano Prof | Update your profile
4600 Sunset Ave, Indianapolis IN 46208

Kate Boyd

Read more from Kate Boyd

Dear Friends, Before we get started: a lot of you have told me that one of your biggest struggles is practicing consistently: not just knowing what to practice, but actually showing up and doing it regularly. I'm working on a video about this and I want to make sure it speaks to what you're actually dealing with. I put together a quick 2-question survey. It's anonymous, takes about 2 minutes, and your answers will directly shape the video. You can fill it out here. Anyway, today I want to...

Dear Friends, For those of you in the Louisville, KY, area, I'll be performing Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel's Das Jahr at the Amy Cralle Theater, Wilson W. Wyatt Center for the Arts, Bellarmine University on Thursday, March 12 at 7:00 pm. It's free and open to the public, and I would love to see you there! Today while I was practicing, I noticed that my jaw was clenched and I was holding tension in my left shoulder. And so I decided to write about something that I work on with my students almost...

Dear Friends, A few months ago I set up a survey to start collecting responses from my viewers and readers. So far I have received more than 2,100 responses to the survey. If you haven’t taken it yet and you’d like to, here’s the link. It has been really interesting to read your stories and learn more about you, and I'm truly grateful for all that you have shared with me. One pattern I've noticed is that hundreds of you articulate a version of the same frustration: feeling discouraged about...